Skip to content

During October 26, 660 parent/carers & young people accessed our service which led to a total of 2,944 calls, emails/contact forms, meetings. 

Essex SEND IASS
Contact us

If the local authority decides not to issue an Education, Health & Care (EHC) plan, their decision letter should explain your rights to mediation and appeal.  

Before deciding whether to appeal, it is important to understand why the local authority reached its decision.  We would encourage you to continue discussing your concerns with the local authority and ask any questions you may have. Gathering as much information as possible can help you decide whether an appeal is appropriate and will be important if you choose to challenge the decision. 

Before appealing you must firstly consider mediation, this can be really useful for example, where you have some additional information or a new report you would like to share with the local authority.

Find out more about Mediation

What does the law say?

The SEND Code of Practice 2015 says:

'Where, despite appropriate assessment and provision, the child or young person is not progressing, or not progressing sufficiently well, the local authority should consider what further provision may be needed. The local authority should take into account:

 

  • whether the special educational provision required to meet the child or young person’s needs can reasonably be provided from within the resources normally available to mainstream early years providers, schools and post-16 institutions, or
  • whether it may be necessary for the local authority to make special educational provision in accordance with an EHC plan'

(9.55)

What makes an EHC plan necessary for my child?

The reasons for challenging a decision not to issue an EHC plan will usually fall into one or more of the following areas:

  • Your child’s needs were not fully understood before the EHC needs assessment, which may mean that the support previously provided was not appropriately matched to their needs.
  • Your child is not making enough progress, despite receiving suitable support.
  • The special educational provision your child needs cannot reasonably be provided without an EHC plan, for example because the level of support required goes beyond the resources normally available to the setting, or because a specialist placement may be needed.

What do we mean by "progress"?

Progress is not just about academic achievement. It can relate to any of the four broad areas of need:

  • Communication and interaction
  • Cognition and learning
  • Social, emotional and mental health
  • Sensory and/or physical needs

For more information, see paragraphs See 6.28 to 6.34 of the SEND Code of Practice for a full definition

What about funding?

Schools and colleges can apply for High Needs (top-up) funding for some children and young people without an EHC plan. If you believe an EHC plan is necessary, you will need to explain why your child's needs are beyond what the setting can reasonably provide using the funding and resources available to them.

Read our information on funding

Things to consider

If the local authority's assessment has identified additional support that they believe the school or college can reasonably provide without an EHC plan, it can be more difficult to challenge their decision. You may need to show why that support is still not enough to meet your child's needs.

It is important to look carefully at:

  • What support the local authority expects schools and colleges to provide from their own resources.
  • What support is already in place for your child.
  • Whether that support is helping your child make sufficient progress.

You can find information about the support generally available in schools and colleges through the Essex Local Offer. If you cannot find the information you need, you can ask the local authority for details by email or letter.  Read our information on on SEN Support in Education Settings

 

Supporting Evidence

Read the school's SEN policy, SEN Information Report and accessibility plan (explains adjustments made for disabled pupils and ongoing plans to improve access). You can print off or screenshot anything that is relevant. 

Some examples of supporting evidence are:

  • Your child/young person's views
  • Progress reports
  • One Plan/IEP/support plan/pupil passport/provision map
  • School costs - budget required for provision
  • Home/school diaries
  • Assessment/specialist reports
  • Exclusion letters/reports
  • Letters/emails from setting/local authority/health/specialist
  • Examples of school or homework (can be helpful where rate of progress is in dispute)
  • You can request a copy of your child's school record (you will likely be charged for photocopying)

If you can't find something you can request information from school or read more in our section on Appealing a LA decision on an EHC plan 

Consider the local authority view

The decision letter from the local authority should explain why they decided not to issue an Education Health and Care plan.

In reaching their decision the local authority should consider:

  • the information gathered during the EHC needs assessment
  • the child or young person's SEN
  • the Special Educational Provision being made

Where the child or young person is not making expected progress, despite appropriate provision they should consider:

  • any further Special Educational Provision needed
  • whether the required provision could reasonably be provided from within the resources normally available to the education setting or
  • whether it is necessary for the local authority to make special educational provision in accordance with an EHC plan

They may have suggested changes to provision and you will need to consider your counter-argument here as to why you believe this provision can only be met by having an EHC plan.

Consider the setting/school view

Where the setting are in support of your case, they are likely to be happy to share with you any supporting evidence, for example, a provision map outlining the required provision and related costs. They may also agree to provide a witness statement in support of your case - see further down information about witnesses.

SEND Appeal Resolution Meetings (SARM)

The SEND Tribunal is introducing SEND Appeal Resolution Meetings (SARM) to support earlier resolution of some Special Educational Needs and Disability (SEND) appeals. SARM is a structured, facilitated discussion that takes place during the tribunal appeal process and provides parents, carers and local authorities with an opportunity to explore whether issues can be resolved before a full hearing is required.

The SARM pilot will initially focus on the Refusal to carry out an Education, Health and Care (EHC) Needs Assessment and Refusal to issue an Education, Health and Care Plan.

The pilot will start late September and will run for a 12-month period.

SARM does not replace the tribunal’s role in determining appeals. Where agreement cannot be reached, the appeal simply continues through the tribunal process as planned.

To find out more about these meetings, download these guidance from HM Courts & Tribunal Service

SEND Appeal Resolution Meetings

How to prepare for your SARM

What if school are not in support?

In this circumstance the local authority will be likely to include information from school as evidence for their case, so it is important to understand the arguments you will be up against.

Talk to school about why they do not feel an EHC plan is necessary, and how they will be able to make the provision without one. Where they disagree about the rate of progress, use the opportunity to unpick this further.

Remember when we talk about progress this should not be limited to academic attainment, there may be wider needs which are having an impact to your child's learning. Consider whether the provision proposed meets all the needs of your child.

Witnesses

You can ask professionals to be your witness, establish whether they will be in support of your appeal. You can ask if they will provide a letter or report which helps you to evidence your key points, that you can include in your appeal.

You could ask if they will come along to the hearing, if they decline you can request a summons for them to attend - before you do this be sure they intend to support your case!

SENDIASS Tribunal Workshops

SENDIASS are offering free online workshops on how to lodge an appeal and what happens after lodging an appeal.

Find out about our training on Training

How to lodge an appeal

Find out how to lodge an appeal on our information pages Appealing a LA Decision about an EHC plan